That's why i strongly disagree with the Abuela is the problem theory. Mirabel didn't get a gift, but the way Alma speaks about it, it makes it seem like Mirabel did something wrong. Rather, she is a strong and determined matriarch who loves her large family and works hard to ensure their safety. Encanto characters watch Encanto! - Chapter 6 - Archive of Our Own Abuela is clearly disappointed and resentful of her granddaughters decision and may have chosen to deny her a gift out of spite. Maybe it is for some of you because you have some unresolved issues with older relatives in your own home, and Abuela's actions throughout most of the movie reminded you of that and her apologies made you realize that these relatives DIDN'T do what she had the guts and sudden self-awareness to do. View complete answer on encanto.fandom.com What was everyone's power in Encanto? What is her problem? However, it also adds an interesting angle to Mirabel's story. @media(min-width:0px){#div-gpt-ad-remodelormove_com-medrectangle-4-0-asloaded{max-width:300px!important;max-height:250px!important}}if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,250],'remodelormove_com-medrectangle-4','ezslot_11',155,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-remodelormove_com-medrectangle-4-0');By taking out these frustrations and feelings of loneliness onto Mirabel and making her feel guilty and scared, Abuela can make Mirabel feel that she needs her and that she has not been completely abandoned by her daughter. Reddit, Inc. 2023. Abuelo Pedro was captured by military forces and tortured, before being killed as an example of what would happen to those who resisted or oppose the new military government. Abuela was incredibly proud of the young woman Isabela had become and was committed to helping her reach her highest potential. Huge fan of Fozzie Bear. Abuela's voice cuts across the room. the resentment falls away, and they're laughing and having fun together - possibly like how they were before mirabel's gift ceremony? Through the healing process and their developing relationship, Mirabel and Abuela started to understand one another, and the two were able to build trusting and supportive relationship. In the beginning, Abuela acts like Mirabel is useless for not having a power, and that the best thing she can do is stand to the side while the others work. Abuela was insistent on them having another child to add more powers to the family, as she was obsessed with her familys legacy and protecting the town through their unique abilities. this may even explain why in "all of you", when the family is singing to mirabel, the line "we see how brave you've been" was given to isabela (and luisa). However, saying sorry is not always sufficient to heal the damage caused, and sometimes action is needed to demonstrate the commitment to change and improve. To view the purposes they believe they have legitimate interest for, or to object to this data processing use the vendor list link below. Abuela came from a long and proud lineage, and seeing Isabela made her feel a deep sense of pride and admiration. The movie is a heartwarming tale of family, love, and resilience, and all the characters, including Abuela, contribute towards this message. Sheis also harsh on other members of the Madrigal family, but Mirabel becomes distinctively left out. Like Mirabel, Abuela lacks a tangible magical ability like super hearing or seeing the future, but rather acts as the glue that holds the rest of the family together. Its possible that Abuela played a role in the situation, but its also likely that other factors were at play. Why is Isabela such a jerk to Mirabel throughout most of the movie? But why? Dolores refused to look at Abuela as she started reading. Powers and Abilities Abuela Alma doesn't possess any particular gift, due to being the one who found the miracle that blessed the Madrigal family in the first place. The actual villain in Encanto was a group of shamans and their leader, El Rey, who wanted to use the special powers of Abuelas grandchildren to unbalance nature and bring a new age of darkness and destruction. Described as "Seorita Perfecta" by her youngest sister, Isabela is the golden child of the Madrigal family, whose gift is the power to conjure beautiful flowers and plants. In addition, some cultures and social norms place a greater emphasis on apologies and forgiveness than others. Continue with Recommended Cookies. Discover short videos related to why abuela is always mean to mirabel on TikTok. Every Song In Encanto Ranked Worst To Best - /Film At the same time, as Casita also loved the family, it didn't leave Mirabel entirely powerless, and it gave her its own magic, allowing her to communicate with Casita. Home Encanto, Casa Madrigal Personal information Affiliation Madrigal Family Occupation Matriach Relatives Pedro Madrigal (husband) Julieta Madrigal (daughter) Pepa Madrigal (daughter) Bruno Madrigal (son) Flix Madrigal (son-in-law) Agustn Madrigal (son-in-law) Isabela Madrigal (granddaughter) Dolores Madrigal (granddaughter) It is important to recognize signs of gaslighting and seek help if you or someone you know is experiencing it. Grandma encouraged Mirabel to pursue her dreams and supported her through thick and thin. She was a little overprotective of her grandchildren and had a hard time accepting change, however her intentions were pure. You can understand where that anger and resentment comes from, but there's no justification for targeting Mirabel, outside of "I need to be perfect and she messes that up." CervusLavandula 1 yr. ago Why is Abuela so disappointed in Mirabel when she also doesn't have a gift? As the film reaches its crescendo, we learn all this Madrigal pain is what's causing the magic to fade. But Abuela's power may actually be the most important of all the Madrigals' abilities. 's ending, in which powerless Mirabel saves the miracle, Encanto Subtly Revealed Its Mirabel Power Twist At The Beginning, Encanto's Unique First Makes A Disney Trend Much Darker. Another significant trauma that Abuela experienced was losing her husband, Pedro, Mirabels grandfather. "I don't think Abuela was fully aware . What REALLY cut deep (for me at least) was the realization that Abuela believed that everything Mirabel does was a malicious act to destroy the family for not receiving a gift during the ceremony. @media(min-width:0px){#div-gpt-ad-coalitionbrewing_com-leader-2-0-asloaded{max-width:300px!important;max-height:250px!important}}if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,250],'coalitionbrewing_com-leader-2','ezslot_14',154,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-coalitionbrewing_com-leader-2-0');In examining the situation, it is clear that Abuela is struggling with a deep sense of grief and loss after the familys painful breakup. Born into the Madrigal family . Maybe if the others members of the family had told her to stop putting pressure over them, she would have listened and realized that her attitude was not good, way before. All rights reserved. in which case, isabela would've grown up with the majority of alma's positive attention, and likely would've been by alma's side for a disproportionately large amount of her life. i got bored and i had to do homework so instead i made thisall credit for footage goes to Disney:) thank you for reading! Throughout the course of Encanto, it becomes evident that Abuela is a highly traditional and conservative figure who holds a great deal of power and influence within the family. After the war, her family was forced to leave their home and move to Paris, where they lived in exile for the next several decades. I think what really cut deep was NOT the fact that Abuela - Reddit A hint at Abuela's "power" reveals itself during Antonio's ceremony (where we learn his power is talking to animals). how to become a biomedical scientist. Discover abuela being mean to mirabel stich 's popular videos - TikTok The problem is all the family. But it seems clear fromEncanto's ending, in which powerless Mirabel saves the miracle, that everyone has an important role to play. It began with her and Pedro, and it continues through her keeping of the candle and her love for all of her children and grandchildren. rare mushroom bee swarm. Why does Mirabel see Isabella in the vision? All of these examples allude to Mirabel's ability to one day take on Abuela's gift, her matriarchal mantle. 1 day ago, by Eden Arielle Gordon More: Encanto: The Real Colombian Location Behind One Of Its Most Crucial Scenes. All these factors could have contributed to Abuelas hostile behavior towards Mirabel. Ultimately, whether or not Mirabel will take over for Abuela depends on the nature of Abuelas role in the story as well as the expectations of the other characters in the story. In terms of Abuela Alma's gift, then, the film indicates that she may have powers in regard to her stewardship of the magical candle, Casita, the family, and the community. She is the eldest daughter of Agustin and Julieta Madrigal, and the older sister of Luisa and Mirabel. Published Feb 2, 2022 Encanto may not have a villain but, to many, Abuela comes awfully close. This form of emotional abuse is a serious issue, as it can have long-lasting effects on a persons mental health and well-being. Grandma had wanted a daughter for a long time, but was unable to have one of her own. She expresses her frustrations through making cruel and hurtful comments and belittling Mirabel which leads her to develop a low self-esteem. In each case, it's hard to say whether the family members receive these powers because they match their unique natures, or vice versa. However, through the events of the film, she comes to realize the significance of letting go of the past and trusting the next generation to carry on the Madrigal legacy. Its possible that the recent damage to the house caused Abuelas magic to falter, which in turn prevented her from awarding a gift to Mirabel. Her counterpart seemed to have such a good relationship with Abuela. While some may argue that Abuelas strict adherence to family traditions and expectations may create tension within the family, it is ultimately her love and devotion to her loved ones that brings them all together in the end. But that is no reason to paint her with a broad brush and claim that her change of heart could never actually happen in real life or would never. All she does is be rude, mean, and degrading towards her! Abuela probably realized how she drove another person in her life away at that point when Mirabel went off to the river. 21 hours ago, by Eden Arielle Gordon the resentment turning into affection in the middle of a song, whilst very disney-esk, could serve as proof of this. Alma Madrigal | Disney Wiki | Fandom Archived post. All of these pressures can be difficult to handle and in some ways overwhelming, but Abuelas intentions are noble and meant to help the Madrigal family reach their fullest potential. Ultimately, she is a well-rounded, non-evil character who is just trying to make her family happy. This could be another little hint of their shared gifts, perhaps indicating that Mirabel is the next in the family line to step into Abuela's shoes to take care of the family as the keeper of their gifts and their home. She is seen as the nurturing and supportive backbone of the family, always there to offer guidance, impart wisdom and provide comfort to anyone who needed it. Encanto Theory: Mirabel's Lack Of Gift Is Due To Abuela's Mistakes Why Did Abuela Have To Be So Mean 3339views Discover short videos related to Why Did Abuela Have To Be So Mean on TikTok. Under the surface, "Encanto" is a celebration not of community, but of selfishness. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Related: Encanto Ending: Does Mirabel Have A Power Now? Everyone bashes abuela for being the problem of their family - Reddit This theory fits well with Encanto's themes of generational trauma and finding a unique individual voice that the movie dealt with. Watch popular content from the following creators: tylerspradley(@ipostrandomthings_tt), CmCake(@justinthebitchwitch), yazzers1(@yazzers1), lilpaul(@reallilpaul), Winnie Rebecca(@winnierebeccaa), Cole Hernandez(@coleneedssol01), Grace(@evavargas41), Judywilkinssmith(@judywilkinssmith), Maddoxed08 . so, the resentment towards mirabel doesn't come from a genuine place that isabela reached on her own, as instead, it was isabela trying to do what she thought alma would want in the service of winning her approval. Her trauma has led to her becoming a rigid and traditional leader, who struggles to adapt to change and let go of the past. Cut to Mirabel sneaking around Casita. The deprivation of a home and her sense of belonging as well as the loss of a secure identity, especially when she and her family were denied citizenship in Paris, no doubt caused Abuela great pain and guilt. I feel like people accusing her apology to Mirabel of being "unrealistic" tend to not take into account that it makes sense that she would apologize. This theory illustrates that Mirabel never needed to prove herself to Abuela, but rather only to herself. The family are what sustain their miracle, not the candle itself. Growing up, Abuela was forced to take on more responsibilities and become the mother figure for her siblings. Mirabel's Secret Gift Explains Why Abuela Doesn't Actually - YouTube She never hated Mirabel, she just assumed she was causing trouble and acting out when she wasn't. Yes, Alma have made different mistakes and she was putting too much pressure on the family. What is the symbol behind the Rolex watch in Hawkeye. Familial love is what maintains the miracle and Abuela Alma has been undercutting it for years. If Abuela did something that greatly affected Mirabels life or caused her a lot of pain, it may be harder for Mirabel to forgive her. And just asEncanto's ending reveals the true nature of Mirabel's magic ability to heal the family, it does the same for Abuela, too. By signing up, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive emails from POPSUGAR. This Fan Theory about Abuela From Encanto is a Head Scratcher - TVovermind Abuelas intentions may have been for the good of the family, but her actions led to an environment of pressure and endless expectations for her children and grandchildren. Abuela witnessing the violent death of her husband and then being forced to raise triplets without him was the event that brought about the Madrigal magic, and while it wasa wonderful offering, it wasn't without its sadness, especially as the events actually mirror real Colombian history. When Mirabel came into her life as an adopted daughter, Grandma was overjoyed and decided that she wanted to make Mirabels life as special as possible. In addition to her obsessions with writing and movies, Ruth also loves dogs, cooking, and adventuring in the great outdoors. Alma wishes to bring harmony and security to the family, in spite of the various forces working against them. Bruno stayed in the walls,yes, but she didn't know that.What he did was basically run away. @media(min-width:0px){#div-gpt-ad-coalitionbrewing_com-large-mobile-banner-1-0-asloaded{max-width:300px!important;max-height:250px!important}}if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,250],'coalitionbrewing_com-large-mobile-banner-1','ezslot_12',152,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-coalitionbrewing_com-large-mobile-banner-1-0');This not only invalidates Mirabels cherished memories but also makes her doubt her own recollection of events. The embrace was a physical manifestation of the love they shared, and it was a way for Mirabel to show that, regardless of Abuelas secret, she was still their beloved family member who was worthy of love and respect. In other disneys, you always have some multiple characters who fight against the villain. It seems not having power is the worst fate possible for anyone in the family. All of this trauma Abuela has experienced has shaped her personality and the way she interacts with the world. and our @media(min-width:0px){#div-gpt-ad-remodelormove_com-leader-3-0-asloaded{max-width:250px!important;max-height:250px!important}}if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[250,250],'remodelormove_com-leader-3','ezslot_19',164,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-remodelormove_com-leader-3-0');The trauma she endured throughout her lifetime deeply affected her, and she never fully overcame it. Abuela treasures the ceremony in whichthe future generations get their gift, and whenMirabel doesn't receive one, she becomes cold towards her, despite not overtly having a gift herself. She created an environment where her children felt ignored and underappreciated, leading one of her daughters, Luisa, to leave and estrange herself from the family. Abuela is the matriarch of the Madrigal family and the keeper of their magical home. Why is Abuela so hard on Mirabel? Beer Why was Isabella so mean to Mirabel? The plot of Encanto revolves around the magical powers of the Madrigal family, who each possess a unique gift. 5 ._random.editz._ random edits 133views Firstly, Abuela may have a rigid personality and a strong belief in traditional Latina cultural values, which may have caused her to see Mirabels behavior as unacceptable. By sharing the same concealed magical gift, Mirabelpossibly reminds Abuela too much of herself. Youd think there would be a little more solidarity between the powerless family members. she's sad and quiet, after alma discovers them rather than angry and actively frightened - almost like she's resigning herself to no longer being alma's favourite and therefore giving up her own access to alma's love.